By combining studies, a meta analysis increases the. A common criticism of metaanalysis is that the analysis focuses on the summary. These include to improve the precision of the estimate of efficacy. This paper is a basic introduction to the process of meta analysis.
Points to consider in the preparation and transfusion of. A bluffers guide to metaanalysis1 discovering statistics. Metaanalysis is the route to academic fame, fortune, the love of your. Confirmation of previous infection with sarscov2 by a record of a validated diagnostic test at the time of illness b.
Critics may object to my statement that meta analysis involves material good, bad, and indifferent, but consider the study by smith et al discussed in more detail later, which numbered among its authors the originator of the term. Also, you need to consider the size of your metaanalysis dataset. It is updated annually in step with the march release of meddra starting with meddra version 23. Response rather than thinking of metaanalysis as a process of garbage in, garbage out we can think of it as a process of waste management. Inferences made on the regression coe cients are based on these robust standard errors. Across all 946 network metaanalysis comparisons, 45 4. Criticisms of metaanalysis comprehensive metaanalysis. There are, however, a number of accepted regulatory purposes for meta analysis. Metaanalysis uses many quantitative approaches and calculation formulas when compiling multiple research. The operating premise, as illustrated in these examples, is that the. Despite these shortcomings, experience can be a valuable starting point for systematic research, and may provide a wealth of questions to be investigated and ideas to be tested. When more than radiation oncologists were asked about their practice and opinions concerning stereotactic ablative radiotherapy for.
This book provides a comprehensive introduction to performing metaanalysis using the statistical software r. Meta analysis for active surveillance applied points to consider ken hornbuckle, dvm, phd senior epidemiology advisor. For example, gains ranged from percentage points on attitudes and social behaviors to 33 points on academics. Metaanalysis is a quantitative technique that uses specific measures e. Handbook of research synthesis and metaanalysis, the on jstor. Meta analysis refers to a process of integration of the results of many studies to arrive at evidence synthesis normand,1999. In practice, this implies the combination of the results of several individual clinical trials using specialized statistical methodology.
Dsouza aloysius l, rajkumar chakravarthi, cooke jonathan, bulpitt christopher j. To evaluate whether overall positive results are also seen in prespecified subgroups of. As in this example, if the goal of a synthesis is to test the null hypothesis, then metaanalysis provides a mathematically rigorous mechanism for this purpose. International society for clinical biostatistics comments. A total of 17 points to consider were proposed, covering 6 main areas. The purpose of this commentary is to expand on existing articles describing meta analysis interpretation,6,14,42,61 discuss differences in the results of a meta analysis based on the treatment questions, explore special cases in the use of meta analysis, and. Meta analysis for active surveillance applied points to. Office of risk management and pharmacoepidemiology. The event rate for fractures in the usual care group was 0. This book provides a clear and thorough introduction to metaanalysis, the process of synthesizing data from a series of separate studies.
The clear diamond is the weighted mean of all studies. As in this example, if the goal of a synthesis is to test the null hypothesis, then meta analysis provides a mathematically rigorous mechanism for this purpose. Response rather than thinking of meta analysis as a process of garbage in, garbage out we can think of it as a process of waste management. When more than radiation oncologists were asked about their practice and opinions concerning stereotactic ablative. Weights in traditional metaanalysis, inverse variance weights play two roles, first, they produce the most e cient estimate of.
The purpose of this commentary is to expand on existing articles describing metaanalysis interpretation,6,14,42,61 discuss differences in the results of a metaanalysis based on the treatment questions, explore special cases in the use of metaanalysis, and. Second, we include all of the effects in a single statistical synthesis. By contrast, in a metaanalysis we introduce two fundamental changes. The latter is clinically more intuitive, as lower values are considered to put babies at a higher risk, and so lower cut. Metaanalysis, one pivotal trial, internal validity, external validity, selection bias, heterogeneity, extrapolation, assessment of consistency, multiregional clinical trials, centre, interaction test, level of evidence for drug licensing. Points to consider have been developed to provide advice on selected areas relevant to the development of medicinal products in specific therapeutic fields. The handbook of research synthesis and metaanalysis is an illuminating compilation of practical instruction, theory, and problem solving. Mar 15, 2017 after that, lumley 27 developed an indirect treatment comparison technique, known as network meta analysis nma, to compare two treatments in the situation where an indirect comparison between two treatments of interest can be obtained through more than one common comparator or linking treatment. Comparisons of interventions for preventing falls in older. These are some of the ways in which the term research is wrongly used.
Andy field university of sussex what is the point of a metaanalysis. Eligibility of convalescent covid19 patients to donate whole blood or plasma should be based on. It is intended for quantitative researchers and students in the medical and social sciences who wish to learn how to perform metaanalysis with r. When performing a metaanalytic summary you will sometimes know at the start exactly what studies you want to include. An additional advantage is that multilevel metaanalysis does not assume that all studies report on the same time points, in fact, all time points may be different. Need for consistency assessment of the consistency of effects across studies is an essential part of meta analysis. In my metaanalysis, there was no heterogeneity, so a metaregression wasnt even an option. Eular points to consider in the development of classification. The fact that metaanalysis and one pivotal study are addressed as separate topics should be borne out more clearly in the title. Introduction to metaanalysis 21 it is also possible to classify metaanalysis studies into one of two categories. Metaanalysis is the quantitative analysis of the results included in an sr. For example, lotze et al 2001 did a study to see what areas of the brain were activated during anal.
This most commonly involves the statistical combination of summary statistics from various trials but the term sometimes is also used to refer to the combination of. Figure 2 shows the results of a metaanalysis of metoclopramide compared with. By contrast, power for the meta analysis exceeded 99. Critics may object to my statement that metaanalysis involves material good, bad, and indifferent, but consider the study by smith et al discussed in more detail later, which numbered among its authors the originator of the term.
Such analyses are essentially observational, using trials as the unit of enrollment rather than individual patients. Psychologists are typically interested in finding general answers to questions. As such, the book introduces the key concepts and models used in metaanalysis. The purpose of the metaregression is to explain the heterogeneity. Research questions and hypotheses this paper reports on the first largescale metaanalysis of schoolbased programs to promote students social and emotional development. The historical roots of metaanalysis can be traced back to 17th century studies of astronomy, while a paper published in 1904 by the statistician karl pearson in the british medical journal which collated data from several studies of typhoid inoculation is seen as the first time a metaanalytic approach was used to aggregate the outcomes of multiple clinical studies. Figure 2 shows the results of a meta analysis of metoclopramide compared with. Suggestions to improve and expand current definitions were described including the incorporation of antineutrophil cytoplasm antibody and aetiological factors, where known. This book provides a clear and thorough introduction to meta analysis, the process of synthesizing data from a series of separate studies. It was developed and is maintained by a working group charged by the ich management committee. Another 5 things to know about metaanalysis absolutely maybe. The 2017 meta analysis shows that benefits in these areas are long lasting, up to 18 years. Unless we know how consistent the results of studies are, we cannot determine the generalisability of the findings of the meta analysis. Points to consider on validity and interpretation of a metaanalysis and of a single pivotal study, respectively.
An interval of at least 14 days after full recovery. This paper is a basic introduction to the process of metaanalysis. Iona millwood and colleagues1 assessed the associations between cardiovascular risk and genotypepredicted mean alcohol intake in men and women in china. In this issue of the irish microbial quantitative risk assessment networks tutorial series, dr ursula gonzales barron explains meta analysis. However, in many applications pooling of safety data is. By combining studies, a metaanalysis increases the. Introduction to meta analysis 21 it is also possible to classify meta analysis studies into one of two categories. Definition metaanalysis is a quantitative approach for systematically combining results of previous research to arrive at conclusions about the body of research. Metaanalysis methods 344 example of psychometric metaanalysis 346 comparison of artifact correction with metaregression 348 sources of information about artifact values 349 how heterogeneity is assessed 349 reporting in psychometric metaanalysis 350 concluding remarks 351 summary points 351 part 9. Network metaanalysis for the outcome of fractures included 68 rcts, 86 491 participants, and 43 interventions plus usual care.
This unique volume offers the reader comprehensive instruction in the skills necessary to conduct powerful research syntheses meeting the highest standards of objectivity. Outlines the role of meta analysis in the research process shows. The results of the pulmicc trial were recently published. These are distinguished by colour, but otherwise look like the other studies. Points to consider on validity and interpretation of metaanalyses.
This report is about metaanalysis in this narrow area, but the present report should also provide conceptually helpful points to consider for a wider range of applications, such as vaccines, medical devices, veterinary medicines or even products that are combinations of medicinal products and medical devices. It is updated in step with new meddra versions and is a companion document to meddra. The three metaanalysis estimates look quite unimportant by comparison. First, we work directly with the effect size from each study rather than the pvalue. Specifically, the ptc considers the validity and interpretation of this methodology in applications for the marketing. The results suggested that the apparently protective effects of moderate alcohol intake against stroke are largely noncausal.
Metaanalysis results thus will be the basis from which conclusions are drawn about what is known and what to study in the future. Ptc document is an ichendorsed guide for meddra users. Definitions and historical perspective the first definition of metaanalysis was given by gene glass 1976 as the statistical analysis of a large collection of results from individual studies for the purpose of integrating the findings1 glass. Probiotics in prevention of antibiotic associated diarrhoea. It is therefore important that users of metaanalysisboth. However, metaanalysis also allows us to move beyond the question of chapter 2. A metaanalysis of all controlled trials may be valuable to follow up safety signals from less reliable analyses. The goal of some syntheses will be to report the summary. Points to consider regarding the sabrcomet trial the lancet. The use of a meta analysis to provide the pivotal evidence in an application will always be problematic. The 2017 metaanalysis shows that benefits in these areas are long lasting, up to 18 years. What is a metaanalysis in 1976, glass coined the term metaanalysis metaanalysis refers to the analysis of analyses the statistical analysis of a large collection of analysis results from individual studies for the purpose of integrating the findings. However, meta analysis also allows us to move beyond the question of chapter 2.
In this situation, a protocol for the conduct of the meta analysis should still be written. Meta analysis is the quantitative analysis of the results included in an sr. One pivotal study i introduction this ptc provides guidance on two topics. This type of publication type has many potential limitations that should be appreciated by all readers. By contrast, power for the metaanalysis exceeded 99. Meta analysis methods 344 example of psychometric meta analysis 346 comparison of artifact correction with meta regression 348 sources of information about artifact values 349 how heterogeneity is assessed 349 reporting in psychometric meta analysis 350 concluding remarks 351 summary points 351 part 9. Apr 29, 2015 for example, in table 2 the univariate meta.
Meta analysis has become a critically important tool in fields as diverse as medicine, pharmacology, epidemiology, education, psychology, business, and ecology. Of course, this presumes that there is any heterogeneity to be explained. Meta analysis is a statistical technique for combining and summarizing the findings from individual studies. Points to consider have been developed to provide advice on selected areas. Introduction to metaanalysis comprehensive metaanalysis. On the other hand, metaanalysis would furnish the risk assessor and the modeler with meaningful effect size distributions.
The size of the black box represents the weight of the study in the overall meta analysis. Using a variety of statistical methods, some of which were purposebuilt, you can condense a vast amount of information into a single summary. The colour choice is not very good for a colour blind reader and would disappear when printed on a monochromatic printer. This is critically important for the goal of computing and testing a summary effect. Glass, 1976, p3 metaanalysis techniques are needed because only. Metaanalysis has become a critically important tool in fields as diverse as medicine, pharmacology, epidemiology, education, psychology, business, and ecology. The three meta analysis estimates look quite unimportant by comparison.
879 1574 424 1507 1556 1524 1546 150 1186 1232 84 35 704 572 547 197 948 1369 1455 937 293 938 1426 1271 948 372 220 1 1486 1373 713 388 1005 618 743 1201 1415 1380 1291 867